Solution to the impossible puzzles

A few weeks ago, I proposed two Alcazar puzzles that have no solution. Some readers came up with very clever ways to explain why they are impossible. Here is my summary.

 

The key idea is to notice that all the possible lines fall into two categories: those that fill an even number of squares, and those that fill an odd number of squares. When the puzzle is colored like a checkerboard (black, white, black, white...), you can extract important information about these lines (see image).


Solution to the first puzzle

With 18 white squares and 17 black ones, we need an odd path to fill this room, and it needs to start and end on a white square. Unfortunately, there is only one door on a white square. This is why the puzzle has no solution.


Solution to the second puzzle

It was meant to be much harder than the first one, but "jh" (one of the blog's reader) came up with a very elegant solution that I summarize here. Congratulations, jh!

 

Like the first puzzle, this one has an extra white square, which means that the solution must start and end on a white square. We can close all the black exits of the puzzle.

 

Then, let's have a look at the 6x6 area in the bottom right. It has as many white squares as black ones, which means that if we want to fill this area with a single line, this line will need to start on a white square and end on a black one (or vice versa). But now that the puzzle's black exits are closed, this area has only white exits. In conclusion: we cannot fill it with a single line.


One last question remains: could we fill this area with more than one than one line? In other words, could we enter this area, exit, and then enter it again? Let's see...


There are only 3 squares that link this area to the rest of the puzzle and they are white. It means that we must enter and exit on white squares with our first path, and then, enter again on a white square before exiting the whole puzzle (again, on a white square). Each of our lines will cross one extra white square, but the area doesn't have extra white squares.


And that's why the puzzle has no solution.


What about normal puzzles?

Click to play in your browser
Click to play in your browser

When playing some of the advanced puzzles in the real game, using the square colors can be very useful. Look at the first level of the book "The Six Rooms", for example. The upper right room has an even number of squares and 4 exits: 3 are white and one is black. Conclusion: you must use the black one.



I hope that this article was helpful. Don't forget to get the Alcazar app (iOS and Android), and if you like it, leave a comment and a rating!

> Click here for the iOS version

> Click here for the Android version


In other news, you can now get the new edition of my game Manifold from Brainwrights' website.


Have fun!


Jérôme


Write a comment

Comments: 13
  • #1

    Paper writing help from NeedPaperHelp.com (Tuesday, 06 June 2017 08:38)

    These problems, puzzles and question come from lots of superior puzzle folks approximately the world, with you, the readers.

  • #2

    Wonder Woman Jacket (Thursday, 06 July 2017 08:53)

    Our boundlessness baffles expand on that convention with another numerical curve that would be practically unimaginable with hand cutting, a bewilder that tiles toward each path.

  • #3

    Assignment Writing (Monday, 24 July 2017 08:25)

    The impossible covering puzzle the instructions are guileless but the explanation is not. In the outstanding of this article I will try to describe to you why accurately the puzzle is impossible.

  • #4

    order college assignment (Tuesday, 08 August 2017 13:38)

    playing some of the advanced puzzles in the real game, using the square colors can be very useful. Look at the first level of the book "The Six Rooms",

  • #5

    Dissertation Help From DissertationHub.co.uk (Monday, 28 August 2017 09:12)

    I'm sorry, yet the main thing to do now is to proceed onward. He is MARRIED, I know he cherished you, however that was before. You ought to go out and endeavor to be glad as opposed to executing yourself candidly with this person

  • #6

    assignment help experts (Tuesday, 29 August 2017 08:56)

    There were 50 something levels and to advance to each level you had to input an answer somewhere. To find the answer you needed to look in the source code for the page or the properties of an image or follow a trail by searching in Google. To advance you had to edit or change the URL or click on a certain part of the picture.

  • #7

    jaxon (Thursday, 14 September 2017 14:46)

    this line will need to start on a white square and end on a black one (or vice versa). But now that the puzzle's black exits are closed, this area has only white exits. In conclusion: we cannot fill it with a single line.

  • #8

    remy hair extensions (Saturday, 21 October 2017 04:15)

    hhhhhhhhhhhhhh

  • #9

    Do my Essay (Friday, 27 October 2017 12:21)

    Shockingly, if your article point is extreme and you appreciate it, at that point it is highly unlikely you will lead an exhaustive research and endeavor to compose a superb paper.

  • #10

    Pay to Write My Essay for Me UK (Friday, 27 October 2017 12:40)

    There were 50 something levels and to progress to each level you needed to include an answer some place. To discover the appropriate response you expected to look in the source code for the page or the properties of a picture or take after a trail via seeking in Google. To propel you needed to alter or change the URL or tap on a specific piece of the photo.

  • #11

    Do my Essay for me (Friday, 27 October 2017 13:48)

    Your educator will just favor of a unique and custom-composed article, nothing not as much as that. This is the reason our custom paper composing organization will furnish you with top-quality, novel, educational and redid expositions, dependably.

  • #12

    Cool As Ice Biker Jacket (Monday, 20 November 2017 13:22)

    An astound is a diversion, issue, or toy that tests a man's inventiveness or learning. In an astound, the solver is relied upon to assemble pieces coherently, keeping in mind the end goal to touch base at the right arrangement of the confuse.

  • #13

    Bomber Jackets for Women (Saturday, 09 December 2017 17:18)

    The unthinkable covering riddle the guidelines are straightforward however the clarification isn't. In the exceptional of this article I will attempt to depict to you why precisely the astound is unthinkable.

The Incredible Company

© 2013-2014 Jérôme Morin-Drouin - All rights reserved